Abstract geometric composition illustrating when ai agents start choosing brands for us

March 2025 ยท AI & Technology

When AI Agents Start Choosing Brands For Us

Because here's the thing: in a world where AI agents handle more and more of our purchasing, browsing, and decision-making, who exactly is your brand trying to persuade?

Last week, I asked an AI agent to book me a restaurant for Saturday night. Not a recommendation. A booking. It looked at my calendar, cross-referenced my dietary preferences, checked travel time from my apartment, and made a reservation at a place I'd never heard of. I loved it. And then I had a small existential crisis about what this means for brands.

Because here's the thing: in a world where AI agents handle more and more of our purchasing, browsing, and decision-making, who exactly is your brand trying to persuade?

Lululemon's ambassador program doesn't pay athletes millions. It empowers local fitness instructors. The brand is built from the yoga studio floor up, not the broadcast booth down.

We're entering an era where a significant and growing percentage of brand interactions won't involve a human being making a conscious choice. Your AI agent will refill your pantry. It'll book your travel. It'll choose your streaming content. And it'll do all of this based on some combination of your stated preferences, your behavioral data, and whatever optimization function its creators built into it.

This fundamentally changes the game for brand strategy in ways I don't think most marketers have fully internalized.

Consider: emotional advertising works because humans are emotional decision-makers. We choose brands for irrational reasons. Because they make us feel something. Because we saw an ad at the right moment. Because someone we admire uses the product. An AI agent doesn't have feelings. It has parameters.

Does this mean emotional branding is dead? Absolutely not. But it means emotional branding now has to do double duty. It has to work on the human who sets the preferences AND be translatable into the structured data that an AI agent can parse. Your brand needs to be both felt and findable.

Think about it in two layers. Layer one: make the human love you so much that they explicitly tell their agent to prefer you. "Always book Sweetgreen for lunch." "Only buy Seventh Generation cleaning products." This is the power of genuine brand loyalty, and it becomes more valuable, not less, in an agentic world.

"Always book Sweetgreen for lunch." "Only buy Seventh Generation cleaning products." This is the power of genuine brand loyalty, and it becomes more valuable, not less, in an agentic world.

Layer two: win the agent's optimization when no explicit preference exists. This is about structured data, reviews, ratings, clear product descriptions, and being the objectively best match for a given set of parameters. It's SEO's more interesting cousin.

The brands that thrive in the agent era will be the ones that are simultaneously deeply loved by humans and clearly understood by machines. That's a harder brief than most creative directors are used to getting. But it's where we're headed.

I, for one, am fascinated to see which brands figure this out first. My money's on the ones that already have genuine human loyalty. Turns out, meaning is a moat against machines too.